A car that struck the St. David’s North Austin Medical Center’s emergency-room waiting area in February left five people injured and claimed the driver’s life.
The Crash and Injuries
The impact occurred in the waiting area of the North Austin facility, where the vehicle collided with the building’s exterior. Five individuals sustained injuries ranging from minor to severe, and the driver died at the scene. The incident prompted immediate medical attention for all those affected.
The Lawsuit
In May, Levi and Nadia Bernard filed a negligence claim against the hospital system, seeking more than $1 million in damages. Their lawsuit cited medical bills, pain and suffering, and lost wages as the basis for compensation. The suit also highlighted the extensive treatment Nadia received, which lasted several weeks.
The Injured Toddler
The Bernard family’s two-year-old son, Sunny, required hundreds of stitches on his face and head. Court papers detail the extensive surgical procedures he underwent following the crash. His injuries underscore the severity of the incident.
The Settlement
A confidential settlement was reached, with the terms remaining undisclosed. St. David’s has denied any negligence, according to a December 19 court filing. The family’s attorney, Sean Breen, confirmed the agreement on Friday but declined to discuss specifics.
Hospital Response
St. David’s previously stated that patient and visitor safety is a top priority. The system reiterated its policy of not commenting on pending claims or litigation. The settlement, however, suggests a resolution outside of court.
KXAN Investigation Impact
KXAN’s investigation, part of its Preventing Disaster series, examined vehicle crashes into medical facilities nationwide. The series led to a new Austin city law mandating bollards at newly built hospitals. A bill to extend this requirement statewide did not pass during the last legislative session.
Legal Proceedings
The Bernard case was set to go to trial next month, but the settlement effectively closed that chapter. Sean Breen stated he had “no comment” on the upcoming trial. The settlement’s confidentiality keeps the case from proceeding.
KXAN’s Follow-Up
KXAN has reached out to St. David’s for further comment on the settlement. No response has been received yet. The station will update the story if additional information becomes available.
Public Safety Measures
The new bollard law aims to prevent future crashes by creating physical barriers around hospital entrances. It reflects a broader push for safety at medical facilities. KXAN’s reporting has highlighted the need for such measures.
Community Reaction
Local residents expressed relief that the settlement was reached, though many still question the hospital’s safety protocols. The incident sparked discussions about vehicle proximity to medical buildings. Community groups have called for stricter enforcement.
Legal Strategy
The Bernard family’s lawsuit alleged negligence and liability on the part of St. David’s. They sought compensation for medical expenses and emotional distress. The settlement suggests a compromise between the parties.
Hospital’s Position
St. David’s consistently denied negligence in court filings. The system maintained that it adheres to rigorous safety standards. Their public statements emphasize a commitment to patient care.
Settlement Confidentiality
The terms of the settlement remain confidential, a common practice in civil litigation. This secrecy limits public knowledge of the compensation amount. The family’s attorney chose not to disclose details.
Impact on Future Litigation
The settlement may influence how similar cases are handled in the future. It demonstrates the potential for out-of-court resolutions. Courts may consider such outcomes when evaluating liability.
Safety Infrastructure
Bollards installed at new hospitals aim to block vehicular access to vulnerable areas. The design seeks to reduce accidental collisions. Austin’s law reflects this preventive approach.
Legislative Efforts
A statewide bill to expand bollard requirements failed to pass. The legislation would have extended safety measures beyond Austin. The failure highlights challenges in achieving broader policy changes.
KXAN’s Role
KXAN’s investigation brought national attention to vehicle crashes at medical facilities. Their reporting has spurred policy changes at the city level. The station continues to monitor related developments.
Settlement Announcement
The settlement was announced publicly on Friday. Sean Breen confirmed the agreement but declined to share specifics. The family’s attorney emphasized the settlement’s confidentiality.
Trial Status
The case was scheduled for trial next month before the settlement. The agreement effectively dismissed the need for a courtroom proceeding. The parties moved forward with a private resolution.
Closing Statement
St. David’s Healthcare’s settlement with the Bernard family marks a significant moment in the aftermath of the February ER crash. While the details remain confidential, the resolution underscores the complexities of medical liability and public safety.
Key Takeaways
- St. David’s settled a lawsuit over a February ER crash that injured five, including a toddler.
- The settlement terms are confidential, and the hospital denies negligence.
- KXAN’s investigation led to new safety laws requiring bollards at new hospitals in Austin.
The incident and subsequent settlement highlight ongoing concerns about vehicle safety near medical facilities and the role of media investigations in prompting legislative action.
