A motion to clear the names of four men accused of the 1991 Yogurt Shop Murders was filed just weeks after investigators linked the crime to a single suspect, reigniting hope for the victims’ family.
Breakthrough and Motion
The Austin Police Department’s cold case unit used DNA and ballistic evidence to identify Robert Brasher as the suspect and sole actor. The case was the first step in clearing the names of four men “wrongfully accused.” The motion was filed after a break in the case announced in September. The family said the proceedings were expected.
Original Convictions and Overturn
Initially, police arrested Forrest Welborn, Maurice Pierce, Michael Scott, and Robert Springsteen. Scott and Springsteen were convicted and served about ten years. Their convictions were later overturned; Welborn’s and Pierce’s were dismissed, but capital murder charges remained on their records. The case followed them for years.
Family and Innocence Project Reactions
Shawn and Angie Ayers expressed relief. Angie said, “all we ever wanted was truth and justice.” She added, “I mean, ever since we found out that the DNA and the shell casing was linked to someone else, I think, you know, we totally expected it.” She also said, “Look, one thing that none of us, any of the family members ever wanted, was anyone that did not commit the crime.” Angie also said, “She’s not only solved her murder and her friends. But she’s going to help others as well.” The Innocence Project of Texas represents Forrest Welbourn and Maurice Pierce. Mike Ware, executive director, said, “We are grateful that the actual truth has finally come out and grateful for the people who have worked so hard to find the actual truth. This was a horrible crime affecting good people.” He added, “It was followed by horrible injustices that profoundly affected the lives of the wrongly accused men and their families who spent much of their young lives jailed and imprisoned for a horrible crime they had nothing to do with.” The Ayers family continues to advocate for other families with cold cases.
Key Takeaways
- DNA and ballistic evidence linked the 1991 Yogurt Shop Murders to Robert Brasher.
- Four men originally accused were cleared after convictions were overturned or dismissed.
- The family and Innocence Project celebrate the exoneration and continue advocacy for cold case families.
The motion marks a pivotal moment for justice in a case that had haunted the community for decades.
Morgan J. Carter is a Texas-based journalist covering breaking news, local government, public safety, and community developments across Austin. With more than six years of reporting experience, Morgan focuses on delivering accurate, clear, and timely stories that reflect the fast-moving pulse of the city.
At newsofaustin.com, Morgan reports on everything from severe weather alerts and traffic updates to city council decisions, crime reports, and the issues shaping daily life in Austin. Known for reliable fact-checking and a strong commitment to public-interest journalism, Morgan brings readers the information they need to stay informed and engaged.
When not tracking a developing story, Morgan enjoys exploring Austin’s neighborhoods, attending local events, and connecting with residents to share the voices and experiences that define the community.
